Analysis of DEFRA's changing farm budget

Tom Scrope
Aug 11th, 2026
•
8 min read
Area chart: farm payments by scheme in England, 2022 to 2028
Click here to view original post on LinkedIn.

DEFRA recently published what they paid out last year to farmers across their schemes, so time for another dig into the numbers, ahead of the main SFI re-launch in September.

‍

While the budget stayed basically flat between 2021 and 2025 (£2.45bn to £2.60bn) the charts below show the move from direct payments to 'public money for public goods'. Direct payments fell from £1.87bn to £813m (£0 by 2028); the 3 main environmental schemes rose from £433m to £1.39bn (£2bn by 2028).

‍

Area chart: farm payments by scheme in England, 2022 to 2028, direct payments shrinking as the environmental schemes grow
Direct payments (blue) wind down as the environmental schemes take over. £908m of SFI alone in 2025.

‍

I've gone through what public goods the Countryside Stewardship, Capital Grants and SFI schemes actually paid for. This is what £1.82bn bought last year (I split each of the 600-odd actions into one of four groups):

🐦 Biodiversity: £968m

🌱 Soil: £496m

💧 Water: £253m

🏚️ Admin, heritage & access: £98m

‍

Table: the £1.82bn of 2025 scheme payments split by public good, with the biggest actions in each group
All 641 paid actions sorted by what they are for. Biodiversity takes over half, soil just over a quarter.

‍

Alongside that, direct payments were still £813m. But more of the budget is going to non-farmers: of the whole £2.6bn farming spend in 2025, 11.5% (£300m) went to non-farmers (2021: 3.8% / £94m).

‍

Area chart: the whole English farming budget by programme and recipient, 2022 to 2028
The whole farming budget, including the smaller programmes and the money that never reaches a farm (magenta).

‍

Bar chart: share of the English farming budget not paid to a farm, rising from 3.8% in 2020-21 to 11.5% in 2024-25
The share of the farming budget not paid to a farm has tripled since 2020-21.

‍

Half of that £1.82bn in 2025 was from the old SFI23/24 schemes. But the new SFI26 scheme has cut the rate on three of the most popular actions - herbal leys (£382 to £224/ha), winter bird food (£853 to £648/ha), legume fallow (£593 to £532/ha) - and gets rid of the planning actions altogether. Because these were the most popular actions, the same mix that earned £908m under SFI23/24 rates would only earn £662m under SFI26 (a 27% cut).

‍

Waterfall chart: 2025 SFI payments of £908m repriced at SFI26 rates come to £662m
Every SFI action claimed in 2025, repriced at SFI26 rates. Three rate cuts and the cancelled plans take off £246m.

‍

Turned around though, the same £908m at the new rates buys DEFRA 37% more public goods. Assuming demand holds up with lower rates - not unlikely given the original schemes sold out, and 75% of SFI26 Window 1 was reserved within weeks of opening on 30th June - this seems like better value for money. Dropping the management payment is also hard to argue with, and probably the IPM plan too.

‍

Bar chart: hectares the same money buys at SFI26 rates for herbal leys, winter bird food and legume fallow
Turned around: what the same money buys at the new rates. Herbal leys go furthest, up 70%.

‍

But I think there is real public good lost in scrapping the soil and nutrient plans. Some definitely treated them as a box-ticking exercise, but at their best they got a farmer and an advisor round the kitchen table talking about this stuff. My Nuffield Farming Scholarships Trust travels convinced me that money spent getting those conversations going isn't wasted - the Dutch BodemUp scheme just funds 3 visits from a soil advisor, and is heavily oversubscribed. If DEFRA doesn't want to fund plans, could it pay for the visits instead?

‍

The only other things I saw shifting the dial were well-facilitated farmer groups - I'm helping pull together a new Facilitator Forum to support them - or the climate forcing the conversation (the Millennium drought drove no-till adoption in Australia in the late 90s). Perhaps the crazy wet winters and dry springs we're getting all too used to will drive those conversations anyway, without SFI nudging them along? 🥵

‍

What do others make of the transition? Where were the missteps? Is SFI26 a sensible tweak or a step backwards? 💡

Subscribe to newsletter

Subscribe to receive the latest blog posts to your inbox.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Your new Farm Management Software - get started today

Free, online, and plenty of time for questions
Upcoming webinars
Click one to sign up: